The Loom of Time: Between Empire and Anarchy, from the Mediterranean to China

** OK, Boomer**

“The Loom of Time” presents itself as a work of meta-history, ambitiously attempting to weave a narrative that connects the thoughts of historical giants like Gibbon and Said. In an era where brand names no longer guarantee widespread readership, Kaplan’s execution doesn’t stick.

The author’s approach to discussing historical debate, particularly the one between Bertrand Russell and Edward Said, comes across as ill-conceived and is indicative of a broader issue within the text. The author feels misaligned with the depth of understanding one might expect from a writer dealing with such esteemed intellectuals. This sense of disconnect is further exacerbated by the author’s own admission of a lack of intimate knowledge of the regions under discussion. Acknowledging neither residency in the concerned areas nor proficiency in the relevant languages, it’s as if Kaplan takes pride in his ignorance.

Given the immense potential of the subject, it is unfortunate that “The Loom of Time” does not fulfill its promise. For readers seeking a rich, informed, and nuanced exploration of meta-history, the search continues.